Aniston and Bateman are plausible as best friends but this script (based on Jeffrey Eugenides's short story "Baster"), oy! Josh Gordon and Will Speck co-directed.
I'd wanted to watch this movie for years, because of the cast and director, but it just didn't click with me today, although I did boost it from a C- to a C because the opening credits are so good. And at least this movie isn't as cringey as MASH, although nowhere near as fascinating as Gosford Park, or as weirdly lovable as Popeye.